Disciplined Quality Evaluation
This skill systematically assesses product or service attributes against defined criteria, ensuring consistent and objective quality evaluations for better decision-making.
Install on your platform
We auto-selected Claude Code based on this skill’s supported platforms.
Run in terminal (recommended)
claude mcp add disciplined-quality-evaluation npx -- -y @trustedskills/disciplined-quality-evaluation
Or manually add to ~/.claude/settings.json
{
"mcpServers": {
"disciplined-quality-evaluation": {
"command": "npx",
"args": [
"-y",
"@trustedskills/disciplined-quality-evaluation"
]
}
}
}Requires Claude Code (claude CLI). Run claude --version to verify your install.
About This Skill
What it does
This skill provides structured and disciplined evaluation of generated text. It assesses outputs against defined criteria, providing a detailed breakdown of strengths and weaknesses. The skill aims to improve the quality of AI agent responses through rigorous analysis and actionable feedback.
When to use it
- Reviewing draft content: Evaluate marketing copy or blog posts before publishing to ensure clarity and accuracy.
- Assessing chatbot performance: Analyze chatbot conversations for tone, helpfulness, and adherence to brand guidelines.
- Improving code generation: Critique generated code snippets for efficiency, readability, and correctness.
- Evaluating creative writing: Provide feedback on stories or poems based on specific literary criteria.
Key capabilities
- Structured evaluation against defined criteria
- Detailed breakdown of strengths and weaknesses
- Actionable feedback for improvement
- Assessment of tone, clarity, accuracy, and adherence to guidelines
Example prompts
- "Evaluate this marketing copy: [paste text here] using the following criteria: clarity, persuasiveness, call to action effectiveness."
- "Assess this chatbot conversation transcript for helpfulness and politeness. Highlight areas needing improvement."
- "Critique this Python code snippet for efficiency and readability: [paste code here]."
Tips & gotchas
The quality of the evaluation heavily relies on clearly defined criteria provided in the prompt. Vague or missing criteria will result in less useful feedback.
Tags
TrustedSkills Verification
Unlike other registries that point to live repositories, TrustedSkills pins every skill to a verified commit hash. This protects you from malicious updates — what you install today is exactly what was reviewed and verified.
Security Audits
| Gen Agent Trust Hub | Pass |
| Socket | Pass |
| Snyk | Pass |
🌐 Community
Passed automated security scans.