Scholar Evaluation
This skill analyzes text to assess its scholarly quality – useful for verifying research and identifying credible sources.
Install on your platform
We auto-selected Claude Code based on this skill’s supported platforms.
Run in terminal (recommended)
claude mcp add jimmc414-scholar-evaluation npx -- -y @trustedskills/jimmc414-scholar-evaluation
Or manually add to ~/.claude/settings.json
{
"mcpServers": {
"jimmc414-scholar-evaluation": {
"command": "npx",
"args": [
"-y",
"@trustedskills/jimmc414-scholar-evaluation"
]
}
}
}Requires Claude Code (claude CLI). Run claude --version to verify your install.
About This Skill
What it does
This skill, jimmc414-scholar-evaluation, provides capabilities to evaluate academic papers based on provided criteria. It can assess factors like relevance, methodology, and clarity. The tool aims to offer a structured assessment of scholarly work, potentially aiding in literature reviews or research selection processes.
When to use it
- Literature Review: Quickly assess the suitability of potential papers for inclusion in a review.
- Research Selection: Prioritize papers based on specific criteria when searching for relevant research.
- Grant Proposal Evaluation: Provide a structured evaluation of existing scholarship supporting a grant proposal.
- Course Assignment Grading: Assist instructors in evaluating student submissions or assigned readings.
Key capabilities
- Paper evaluation based on provided criteria
- Assessment of relevance, methodology, and clarity
- Structured assessment output
Example prompts
- "Evaluate this paper: [paper URL] focusing on its methodological rigor."
- "Assess the relevance of this article to my research on [topic]: [paper URL]"
- "Can you provide a structured evaluation of this paper, considering clarity and contribution? [paper URL]"
Tips & gotchas
The quality of the evaluation depends heavily on the specificity and clarity of the criteria provided. Providing clear guidelines will improve the accuracy and usefulness of the assessment.
Tags
TrustedSkills Verification
Unlike other registries that point to live repositories, TrustedSkills pins every skill to a verified commit hash. This protects you from malicious updates — what you install today is exactly what was reviewed and verified.
Security Audits
| Gen Agent Trust Hub | Pass |
| Socket | Pass |
| Snyk | Pass |
🌐 Community
Passed automated security scans.